How Confidence Beats Technique in Golf

I've seen it happen countless times over my coaching career: a technically flawed golfer who consistently outscores players with picture-perfect swings. Last month, I watched it play out again during a club championship.

One player had a swing that looked like it came straight from an instruction manual—perfect positions, textbook mechanics, beautiful to watch. The other player had what I'd politely call "homegrown" technique—unconventional grip, unorthodox backswing, moves that would make a swing purist cringe.

The technically perfect player shot 79. The unconventional player shot 73.

The difference? Pure, unshakeable confidence.

The Confidence Paradox

Here's what I've learned after two decades of coaching: confidence matters more than technique in competitive golf. Not because technique isn't important—it absolutely is—but because all the technical skill in the world won't help you if you don't trust yourself to execute it.

I see technically sound golfers self-destruct on the course every week. They have great practice swings. They understand swing mechanics better than most teaching professionals. But when it's time to hit the shot that counts, doubt creeps in and their beautiful technique falls apart.

Meanwhile, I watch players with quirky swings—moves that "shouldn't work"—shooting consistent scores because they have absolute faith in their ability to get the ball where they need it to go.

The question every golfer asks me is: "How do I develop that kind of confidence?"

And here's the answer most don't want to hear: you can't buy it, fake it, or think your way into it. You have to earn it.

The Only Way to Build Real Confidence

True confidence—the kind that holds up under pressure—comes from one source: evidence.

The confidence that you can bounce back from a bad hole is earned by working through previous bad holes and recovering. The confidence that you can hit your driver in the fairway is earned by the previous drives you've successfully hit. The confidence that you can make a four-footer for par is earned by the previous four-footers you've made in similar situations.

You can't shortcut this process. You can't just decide to be confident. Your brain doesn't work that way. Your nervous system needs proof, and the only way to provide that proof is through accumulated experience of success.

This is why positive thinking alone doesn't work in golf. You can stand on the first tee telling yourself "I'm confident, I'm confident, I'm confident," but if you don't have a history of successful first tee shots to back up that statement, your brain knows you're lying.

The Players Who Play Beyond Their Technique

Let me tell you about two students who illustrate this perfectly.

The first student has what most would call a "problematic" swing. His grip is strong, his backswing is short and flat, and his follow-through looks restricted. By conventional standards, he shouldn't be able to score well.

But he shoots in the mid-70s consistently. Why? Because he's earned complete confidence in that unconventional swing through thousands of repetitions. He knows exactly how his ball is going to fly. He trusts his patterns completely. When he steps up to a shot, there's no doubt in his mind about what's going to happen.

The second student has a swing that any instructor would admire. Perfect positions, ideal mechanics, everything by the book. He should be shooting par or better.

Instead, he struggles to break 85. Why? Because despite his technical proficiency, he hasn't earned confidence in his ability to execute under pressure. He's still learning his swing patterns. He doesn't fully trust them yet. So when it matters, he second-guesses and tentatively executes what should be a solid technical foundation.

The unconventional player has earned his confidence through repetition and proven results. The technically sound player is still building his evidence bank.

Courage First, Confidence Later

Here's something crucial to understand: you can't start with confidence. Nobody does. You start with courage.

In the beginning, you need enough courage to practice even though it may not go very well. Courage to hit shots that might not work. Courage to try techniques that feel awkward. Courage to play rounds where you'll probably struggle.

This is where most golfers get stuck. They want to feel confident before they try, but that's backwards. Confidence is the result of trying, not the prerequisite.

I see this with new students all the time. They come to me wanting to feel confident about their swing before they'll commit to it. But confidence doesn't come from understanding. It comes from doing.

You have to have the courage to hit imperfect shots during practice. The courage to play rounds where you might not score well. The courage to enter competitions before you feel ready.

And over time, as your skills improve and your evidence bank grows, courage transforms into confidence. You start to trust your swing because you've seen it work. You start to believe in your ability to recover because you've done it before. You start to feel confident over pressure putts because you've made similar putts in the past.

Building Your Evidence Bank

So how do you actually build the kind of confidence that translates to better golf? You systematically create evidence.

1. Track Your Successes Most golfers only remember their failures. Start tracking your successes deliberately. Keep a record of good drives, solid iron shots, successful recoveries, and clutch putts. Your brain needs to be reminded of the evidence that you can do these things.

2. Create Pressure Situations in Practice Confidence under pressure is earned by practicing under pressure. Don't just hit balls mindlessly on the range. Create games with consequences. Play mini-competitions with yourself. Put yourself in situations where the shot matters, even if it's just pride.

3. Build Progressive Challenges Start with shots you can successfully execute 8 out of 10 times, then gradually increase the difficulty. Each successful execution builds evidence. Trying shots that are currently beyond your skill level doesn't build confidence—it erodes it.

4. Review Your Rounds Objectively After each round, identify three things you did well. Not perfect shots, just solid executions. "I successfully got out of three different bunkers today." "I hit 9 out of 14 fairways." "I avoided three-putts all day." This builds your evidence bank.

5. Embrace the Learning Process Confidence isn't about never failing - it's about knowing you can handle failure. The confidence to bounce back from a bad hole comes from having bounced back before. So don't avoid situations where you might struggle. That's where you earn the confidence to recover.

The Student Who Found His Confidence

One of my favorite transformations involved a talented student who had all the technical skills but consistently underperformed in tournaments. His practice rounds were excellent. His range sessions were solid. But put him in competition and he'd fall apart.

The problem wasn't his swing—it was his confidence, or lack thereof.

We created a systematic plan to build his evidence bank. First, we started tracking every successful shot in practice, not just the perfect ones. We wanted him to see how often he actually executed well.

Second, we created pressure situations in practice. We played matches where consequences mattered. We practiced scenarios he'd face in tournaments—difficult par saves, pressure tee shots, crucial putts.

Third, and most importantly, we got him into small competitions where he could build evidence of performing successfully. Not major championships—just club events, local tournaments, casual money games with friends.

The first few didn't go well. But here's what happened: each time he successfully navigated a pressure situation, even if it was just hitting the fairway on the first tee, he was making a deposit in his confidence bank.

Over six months, I watched his tournament performances steadily improve. Not because his swing changed—it barely did. But because he'd earned confidence through accumulated evidence that he could perform when it mattered.

Why This Takes Time

Here's the reality: building genuine confidence takes time because you need to accumulate enough evidence to convince your nervous system that you're capable.

One good round doesn't create lasting confidence. One solid practice session doesn't do it. You need repetition. You need pattern recognition. You need your brain to see enough evidence that it accepts the new belief as truth.

This is why shortcuts don't work. You can't fake this process. You can't think your way to confidence. You have to earn it through consistent, repeated success over time.

But here's the good news: once you've earned it, it's durable. The confidence built through genuine evidence doesn't evaporate after one bad shot or one poor round. It's resilient because it's rooted in reality, not wishful thinking.

Your Path to Earned Confidence

If you want to develop the kind of confidence that allows you to play beyond your technical limitations, here's your assignment:

This Week: Identify one specific shot or situation where you currently lack confidence. Commit to practicing that specific scenario deliberately, tracking your successes, until you've built enough evidence to trust yourself in that situation.

This Month: Put yourself in three situations where you'll have to perform under some level of pressure—a friendly match, a club competition, a round with better players. The goal isn't to score well; it's to gain evidence that you can handle pressure.

This Year: Build a comprehensive evidence bank of your capabilities. Track your stats. Record your successes. Document your recoveries from mistakes. Create proof that you're capable of the golf you want to play.

The Ultimate Truth About Confidence

Here's what I've learned: the golfers who play with the most confidence aren't necessarily the ones with the best swings. They're the ones who have earned the right to trust themselves through accumulated evidence of success.

You can't fake this. You can't shortcut it. You can't think your way into it.

But you can earn it.

Start with courage—the courage to practice imperfectly, to compete before you're ready, to fail and try again. Then systematically build your evidence bank through deliberate practice and progressive challenges.

Over time, courage transforms into confidence. And confidence, more than perfect technique, is what allows good golfers to become great performers.

Confidence isn't given—it's earned. And the earning process is the very thing that makes it real.

Think About This

What evidence do you currently have that supports your ability to play the golf you want to play? And if the evidence is lacking, are you willing to have the courage to start building it today, even if the initial results aren't perfect?

Until next time, less swing thoughts, more great shots!

Owen.

/